Originally posted 5/2/2023
This was me exploring the duty I have as a descendant of colonial settlers, knowing some but not all of my own settler legacy, but very much slipping between fact and fiction, dream and reality. Performance art again.
The idea was #BigLove
I don't know how well I did here, but I'm going to put it back out there, hoping no one wants to murder me for it. It aims to be reverent and sincere but almost certainly fails in some important regards. It's not a historical document. It's art.
Is there a difference? Maybe anthropologists and Indigenous communities can answer that question??? If they can sit in the same room without our First Peoples rightly trying to kill many of them...
Homework for the lay(wo)man: The Inconvenient Indian by Thomas King
xo,
Frank
_______
Dear, Dear Chief Dan George,
Chief Seattle,
and All my Indigenous Relations,
humbly including my local Relations, like the Ltakho Dene, whose territories* I stand on as I speak,
Please skip the following note, which is for other newcomers to Turtle Island like myself.
*These are unceded territories, which for us who don't know yet, means not paid for or treatied or surrendered or traded or otherwise ceded. Most of us don't know this, but pretty much the entire province of BC was never treatied or traded or paid for or otherwise ceded. Do your research if you don't know much about this yet. This is my last direct address to my non-Indigenous Relations here in this post.
All of you above, I wish to know but also wish to respect by keeping a loving distance while I learn how to love with respect.
Trigger Warning: I think the first sentence sort of captures it.
Start here =>
I am so sorry for what my family, my lineage and forbears did to your family and forbears, and to your land and all the life upon it.
I am so sorry.
I cannot say much in our defense. All I can say is that in all honesty, we needed those talking wires to figure out how to find God again, how to find each other again. And in our recklessness, we nearly destroyed you and ourselves, but mostly you.
And I am so sorry for this. We needed you more than you could bear, more than any one could. And in this, we abused you to save ourselves. We stepped on you to lift ourselves up, and we continue to do so, not necessarily because we don’t value you. We certainly could value you a LOT more because you are the gold, the diamonds in the rough. We did this and continue to do this often because we don’t know how to stop. We don’t know how to save ourselves without climbing on top of those who have the wisdom to save us from drowning… because we are drowning.
But more and more of us are starting to learn to swim, and some of us are becoming strong enough to see what we've done and to try, without stepping on you further, to help give you a hand up from where we've shoved you down, to help support your strength rather than tear it down because we still can't stand on our own and don't even know it. The best of us are still doing this.
It is the worst sort of ignorance. Shameful.
For this, I am deeply sorry.
All I can say is that I’m trying to give back what I can of the gifts that were stolen from you and your families for hundreds of years.
This is a terrible, seemingly insurmountable task, this reconciliation, and most of us are too afraid underneath whatever form of defense or offense we show, to even touch it. We can't face it because it is a truly horrific shame what our families did to you and yours.
But to me what is more important than shame, or perhaps more accurately, what is EQUALLY important to the shame is healing, and as always, I need to let it begin with me.
I will work on my swimming and finding the ground of God, the Great Spirit, Yaweh, Zen, Buddha Light, and so on, Mother Earth, beneath me. And I will find a way to share it with you if you want it, and I will wait until I can do this without pulling you down with me.
You know this, but I think it's also important for me to say it to you in recognition. It is not your fault, and it is not your responsibility, me and my family being lost in the depths and confusion of 1000s of years of cultural light and darkness, a lot of darkness the last five or so hundred years, probably more. We have been lost and found and lost for a long time. And this freight train of cultural baggage collided into Turtle Island like its own continent, but instead of pushing up some tremendous yet balanced mountains and hills and lakes and rivers and trees and birds and beasts, we climbed on top of you. And our weight and our diseases very nearly destroyed you. It did destroy so very many of you upon Turtle Island. We were like the Woman who fell from the Sky, and Otter and Duck, and the other animals did try to swim deeper and deeper into the ocean to find the ground and bring it back up to put beneath our feet, except we never found that balance, the balance between the twins the Woman bore.
Please forgive my certain clumsiness in trying to relate. This story has touched my life in very meaningful ways. I mean absolutely no disrespect. I speak of it with reverence. And it is not MY story, I know. It is how I imagine it might have been if we had made true partnership with you all those years ago. It could have been so beautiful.
The death of that beautiful possibility is utterly heart-breaking to me.
If it was simple enough to go back in a time machine and correct everything with one cultural moment, I would go back to the Wampum belt, and tell my forbears what it truly meant, what they were agreeing to, what they were instead agreeding to. You gave us democracy, and we gave you our pain and our fear and our inability to relate to others without dominating them, without raping and robbing them and blaming them for the state we put them in to assuage our true guilt and shame, which we were not strong or wise enough to bear.
We took and took and took and still continue to take even despite our most loving intentions because we were spiritually bereft. Our God had died.
In our hearts we felt betrayed that the atrocities we had ourselves committed were even possible. God couldn't let this happen, could he? He would surely stop us from committing such evils, wouldn't he?
Wouldn't he?
But he didn't.
And we took this to mean that God was dead or never existed at all or had abandoned us.
We are a culture of abandoned children at heart. And in our pain we hurt you, with the same pain we had been hurting each other for as long as we could remember, as long as we CAN remember.
You know this, but I will say it again. It is not your fault, and it is not your responsibility, me and my family being lost in the depths of 1000s of years of cultural light and darkness, a lot of darkness the last five or so hundred years, probably more. We have been lost and found and lost for a long time without a God we could trust.
But in killing our Father God, we also, tragically, killed the Great Mother, the Woman, our source of light, of heaven, our connection to the Great Mystery and the Great Creator, or in our own language, God, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, or just God.
Which is of course neither male nor female but also both or one or the other as they choose or whatever.
Not the man in the sky, but the real thing that is no thing and every thing at the same time but also never into infinity and beyond.
The Omega. No, that word isn't right either. Sigh. Yep, lost.
We were, and still are, spiritual runaways. We are all, many of us, still lost. That is why we culturally appropriate. This is not an excuse, only an answer to the question, Why.
We have been desparately trying to find our way back to the "real God" for centuries, some of us for thousands of years, women in particular. But that's another conversation for another day, and I don't know how to have it yet without being grievously offensive... because I don't yet fully understand it. It IS important. I believe it may be at the root of our bereavement for God, actually, but I don't yet understand its spiritual root or its larger spiritual meaning.
Either way, we were are are still lost.
We became so entranced in our desperate search for the creative mother, thinking we could replace her perhaps? We became so entranced by our own creations, our talking wires and the like that we reveled in them, forgetting to also listen for God in them and tend to the ground beneath our feet, to appreciate those who came before us and still stood with us or, tragically, stood crushed beneath us.
We forgot, or actually, I think we did not know how to let others stand beside us and share in this amazing land and its life.
We had forgotten that it was not US who created it, and we believed a horrendous lying fear that we had to take it from others to have it for ourselves. We did this to each other much like we did it to you, in our old countries.
We learned it there and brought it here, and shared with you what gifts we had, which were actually terrible, terrible burdens and toxins and cancers, and poisons and so on...
When we came, we brought our baggage with us, mostly not realizing it, in childlike and naive optimism but also adolescent hubris. We are still only teenagers in our understanding of ourselves in relationship to the world, to you and to our forbears. And to the land and all life upon earth.
We are idiots.
But we do have love in our hearts, and we are starting to find our own ways back to spirit, in large part due to the gifts of Turtle Island and the buried treasures of our homelands. We are excavating those in a searching and increasingly fearless moral inventory, and some of us are doing the same of what we brought and buried here, too….
Sadly, so many of your children....
God, forgive us. I cry with all my heart of this, not for you to feel sorry for me but because it was and continues to be so, so painfully wrong. I cry in shame. I am sorry.
But I know only God has the power to make this right for us and for you, and so I continue to learn and practice at swimming and finding God beneath me for myself to stand upon and anyone who wishes to stand with me... without climbing on top of me, too.
I, too, have been broken in this way. Do not feel sorry for me. That's not what I mean, not at all.
I cannot know the pain we have brought you and exchanged for your gifts. What I can know is that it does hurt when someone does this to another person in a single lifetime or through a family's generations long wounds passed down from one generation to the next. And I can try to break the pattern. I can try to let the blame stop with me, the responsibility for 1000s of years of pain stop with me, not by being a hero, but through (yes, through, not by) learning to swim and to find God beneath me.
I am still learning how to do this, but it is happening, and I have many people and places and animals and plants and mountains and lakes and rivers and novels and stories and songs to thank for this.
Other's lives, other's stories. We need stories outside of ourselves to learn from, in order to find our own, not to replace our own, but to let those other stories lead us closer and closer to our own, and as we get closer to the center of our own unique stories, through the stories of others, we bring the universal gifts from the stories of others with us. We let go of them. We stop consuming them, eating them and thereby destroying and transforming them for our own purposes. We set them free, in a sense, or stop trying to grasp onto them like life preservers, which they legitimately are at times in our lives, when we gain our own strength and begin to touch the ground of our own individual Truths. It is then, I believe, that our truths can become life preservers to others.
Stories are great gifts. They are gifts that have blessed me, or who have blessed me, I could say. They are gifts I would like to give in return some way some how.
I am still learning how to do this, but it is happening, the ground appearing beneath my feet, I mean.
And when I am ready, I will share my gifts with you. When I understand how, I will share them with you.
So while I cannot promise that I won't hurt you again in my terrible ignorance, hubris, and adolescent angst and confusion (I'm 43 by the way lol), I can promise you this. I am trying with my whole heart and soul to give the world everything I've got, all the gifts I have been blessed with.
I will learn how to find and share the ground beneath me. I will come to know that we are loved.
For your culture did not give me much... it and this land, Turtle Island, gave me everything. My life, my heart and soul. This is a fundamental part of my personal Truth, my story. It is not much. It is everything. But I'm telling you right now, you no longer need to live and die without dignity for me if there is anything I can do about it. I will find a way. That is my promise.
So if you will, when ever, if ever, here is my imperfect offering for you to accept or not. I love you and will keep becoming stronger for if ever one day you want to, we can meet in a safe place of true reconciliation, upon a common ground of Truth and the Great Spirit of Love.
Yours truly,
J
Some Links:
Chief Dan George
https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/the-carillon/local/2021/07/14/column-carillon-flashback-feb-16-1972-chief-dan-george-shares-his-views-of-culture-brotherhood
https://www.strongnations.com/gs/show.php?gs=3&gsd=779
https://www.goodreads.com/author/quotes/644321.Dan_George
Chief Seattle
https://www.washington.edu/uwired/outreach/cspn/Website/Classroom%20Materials/Reading%20the%20Region/Texts%20by%20and%20about%20Natives/Texts/8.html